Identifying Antique Book Editions

Determining the value of antique books often requires knowing whether the book is a first edition. 

Figuring this out is sometimes easier said than done!

Antique books (pre-19th century) often don’t have a print run listed. This makes it very tricky to ascertain the book’s edition.

That’s when an antique book expert comes into play; an expert can help determine the book’s edition through various pieces of information unique to the individual book.

The confirmation of a First Edition will almost always increase the value of antique books, which is why it’s always wise to consult a professional. 

Determining Modern Book Editions

Modern first edition books are usually a lot easier to recognize with a “Number Line”.

You can check for the standard format such as (1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ) where the “1” signifies that the book is a 1st Edition. Often you’ll find a number line such as: ( 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ). In this case, one might easily think that the “2 ” would indicate that it is a Second Edition but in the majority of cases, this isn’t so.

The “2” and increasing numbers signify the printing; therefore, the number line ( 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ) would translate to the book being a 1st edition but a second printing and so on.

Dust jackets and printing errors are clues

First state dust jackets and errors within the text also are major indicators of the editions.

In the early stages of publication, books often contain printing imperfections and errors that have slipped by before being noticed and corrected prior to printing. Such clues are often very helpful in spotting an early printing.

You can’t always apply a general rule to First Editions so it can be more difficult than you’d think to discover a highly collectable edition of a well known First Edition book.

No Printing Year = First Edition? Nope.

One rule that doesn’t always hold true – and is often heard among many (even competent) book sellers:

“If there’s no printing year within the book then it’s definitely a First Edition.”

There are always exceptions, but in many cases a book without a printing year shows it to in fact be a later edition. Later printings can drastically decrease the value of antique books.

Take “Harry Potter” for example

As we all know, J.K. Rowling’s magical series became an instant classic and is one of the most collectible of modern books.

Let’s take – for instance – the First Edition of “Harry Potter”.

The first run – meaning the first printing – of “Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone” only had a printing run of 500 books. A total of 250 of those books were immediately distributed to libraries. 

Since all the little wizards were enthralled with Harry Potter, the next printing run of “The Philosopher’s Stone” was dramatically increased in quantity, running into the thousands.

Therefore, the later the print run on “The Philosopher’s Stone”, the less desirable to collectors today.


Determining a book’s edition can be problematic and confusing for amateurs. If you’re interested in learning more details about the subject, check out Invaluable’s guide to First Edition books here.



Want to sell your first edition book?

We buy first edition books from many eras; use our free Instant Evaluator tool to find out within minutes if you can sell your first edition book to us.

Sell your first edition books